{
 "id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
 "slug": "alliance-carnation-city-mall",
 "type": "mall",
 "name": "Carnation City Mall",
 "aka": [],
 "city": "Alliance",
 "county": "Stark County",
 "state": "OH",
 "country": "US",
 "census_division": 3,
 "lat": 40.91534,
 "lon": -81.10593,
 "geocode_method": "nominatim-city",
 "address": null,
 "metro": null,
 "original_use": "mall",
 "year_opened": null,
 "year_closed": 2022,
 "acres": null,
 "gla_sqft": null,
 "stores_peak": null,
 "levels": null,
 "original_developer": null,
 "original_architect": null,
 "before_notes": "Draft from Wikipedia, model-extracted, unreviewed: Meijer redeveloped the former Carnation City Mall in Alliance, Ohio, into a new Meijer store, opening in 2024.",
 "strategy": [
  "redevelop"
 ],
 "new_use": [
  "retail"
 ],
 "share_retrofit": null,
 "status": "built",
 "year_retrofit": 2024,
 "developer": null,
 "architect": null,
 "after_notes": "new Meijer store",
 "narrative": null,
 "narrative_license": null,
 "narrative_source": null,
 "zoning_change": null,
 "public_subsidy": null,
 "entitlement_year": null,
 "planning_notes": null,
 "wikidata_qid": null,
 "wikipedia": null,
 "osm_id": null,
 "verified": "draft",
 "verified_by": null,
 "last_verified": null,
 "last_updated": "2026-10-18",
 "created": "2026-10-18",
 "contributor_name": null,
 "contributor_org": null,
 "contributor_link": null,
 "international": 0,
 "county_fips": "39151",
 "opp_score": 0.0,
 "opp_reasons": [
  "retrofit already built"
 ],
 "for_sale": 0,
 "distressed": 0,
 "deep": {},
 "elements": [
  {
   "slug": "era-closed-2020s",
   "name": "Closed 2020s",
   "grp": "era",
   "evidence": "2022",
   "origin": "newtypes-extraction"
  },
  {
   "slug": "era-retrofit-2020s",
   "name": "Retrofit 2020s",
   "grp": "era",
   "evidence": "2024",
   "origin": "newtypes-extraction"
  },
  {
   "slug": "strategy-redevelop",
   "name": "Redeveloped",
   "grp": "strategy",
   "evidence": "new Meijer store",
   "origin": "record"
  },
  {
   "slug": "use-retail",
   "name": "Retail (continued)",
   "grp": "use",
   "evidence": "new_use field",
   "origin": "newtypes-extraction"
  }
 ],
 "sources": [
  {
   "id": 7588,
   "site_id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
   "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meijer",
   "title": "Meijer",
   "publisher": "Wikipedia",
   "date": null,
   "quote": "Carnation City Mall",
   "kind": "wikipedia",
   "license": "CC BY-SA 4.0",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-18"
  },
  {
   "id": 7589,
   "site_id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
   "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meijer",
   "title": "Timeline",
   "publisher": null,
   "date": null,
   "quote": "Carnation City Mall, which had closed in 2022.",
   "kind": "quote",
   "license": null,
   "retrieved": "2026-10-18"
  },
  {
   "id": 7590,
   "site_id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
   "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meijer",
   "title": "Timeline",
   "publisher": null,
   "date": null,
   "quote": "In 2024, Meijer opened a store in Alliance, Ohio, on the site of the former Carnation City Mall",
   "kind": "quote",
   "license": null,
   "retrieved": "2026-10-18"
  }
 ],
 "parties": [],
 "events": [
  {
   "id": 4520,
   "site_id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
   "date": null,
   "year": 2022,
   "kind": "note",
   "detail": "Mall closed",
   "share": null,
   "source_id": 7589,
   "verified": "draft"
  },
  {
   "id": 4522,
   "site_id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
   "date": null,
   "year": 2022,
   "kind": "closed",
   "detail": "Closed",
   "share": null,
   "source_id": null,
   "verified": "draft"
  },
  {
   "id": 4521,
   "site_id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
   "date": null,
   "year": 2024,
   "kind": "note",
   "detail": "Meijer store opened",
   "share": null,
   "source_id": 7590,
   "verified": "draft"
  },
  {
   "id": 4523,
   "site_id": "n-9e0ff8bd2b",
   "date": null,
   "year": 2024,
   "kind": "retrofit",
   "detail": "Retrofit: redevelop",
   "share": null,
   "source_id": null,
   "verified": "draft"
  }
 ],
 "gallery": [],
 "anchors": [],
 "deals": [],
 "owner_of_record": null,
 "ctx": {
  "assessment": {
   "what_happened": "Carnation City Mall closed in 2022. A retrofit redevelopment was completed in 2024, opening a new Meijer store. The site is now classified as 'built' under retail use. The project is marked as 'retrofit already built' in opportunity scoring (score 0.0).",
   "why": "The site transitioned from closed mall to retail (Meijer) within the planned timeline. Stark County retail employment remained stable (2012\u20132023), and housing values grew 4.2% YoY. Traffic data shows 10,404 ADT on a principal arterial road (S UNION AVE).",
   "where_it_stands": "No parcel details, deal terms, or post-retrofit performance metrics are provided in the record. The 'verified' status is 'draft', and no further development plans are noted beyond the Meijer opening.",
   "for_a_planner": [
    "Stark County retail trends show stability",
    "Traffic volume supports retail use",
    "No additional parcels or planning documents included"
   ],
   "for_a_developer": [
    "Retrofit completed (2024) with Meijer as anchor",
    "No opportunity score available (0.0)",
    "No data on parcel size, deal terms, or ROI metrics provided"
   ],
   "risks_and_unknowns": [
    "No post-retrofit sales or occupancy data",
    "No details on how Meijer was secured",
    "No context on why retrofit was prioritized over other strategies"
   ],
   "data_quality": "partial",
   "one_line": "Closed 2022, Meijer opened 2024 after retrofit; no further development details in record.",
   "model": "qwen3-30b-a3b-64k:latest",
   "machine": "Dell 5820 RTX 3090 (Ollama, qwen3-30b-a3b)",
   "record_sha1": "af8f4da2e541"
  },
  "elevation": {
   "elevation_ft": 1159.2,
   "resolution": 1,
   "source": "USGS EPQS (3DEP)",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "food_access": {
   "tract10": "39151710300",
   "urban": 1,
   "lila_1_10": 0,
   "low_access_1mi": 0,
   "lapop1share": 4.8631147665076595,
   "poverty_rate": 22.2028480092996,
   "median_family_income": 49524.0,
   "snap_households": 332.0,
   "pop2010": 3602.0,
   "source": "USDA ERS Food Access Research Atlas 2019 (ArcGIS copy)",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "housing_market": {
   "zhvi": {
    "latest": 218921,
    "month": "2026-09",
    "change_1y": 0.042,
    "change_5y": 0.34
   },
   "zori": {
    "latest": 1141,
    "month": "2026-09",
    "change_1y": 0.043,
    "change_5y": 0.35
   },
   "county_fips": "39151",
   "source": "Zillow Research (ZHVI, ZORI)"
  },
  "jobs_lodes": {
   "tract20": "39151710300",
   "jobs": 541,
   "retail_jobs": 21,
   "food_accommodation_jobs": 47,
   "year": 2022,
   "source": "Census LEHD LODES8 WAC 2022 (all jobs, primary and secondary), blocks summed to the 2020 tract",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "listings": {
   "zip": "44601",
   "month": "202609",
   "median_listing_price": 179950,
   "median_listing_price_yy": -0.122,
   "active_listing_count": 81,
   "median_days_on_market": 42,
   "price_reduced_share": 0.1967,
   "pending_ratio": 0.5247,
   "source": "Realtor.com Research, inventory core metrics by ZIP (ZCTA at the site point)",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "opportunity": {
   "tract10": "39151710300",
   "kfr_p25": 0.3627,
   "jail_p25": 0.0319,
   "kids_count": 540.7559,
   "commuting_zone": "Canton",
   "vintage": "children born 1978-83, outcomes measured 2014-15",
   "source": "Opportunity Insights, Opportunity Atlas (Chetty, Friedman, Hendren, Jones, Porter 2018)",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "peers": {
   "peers": [
    {
     "id": "m-e1ba4aac1c",
     "name": "City Center",
     "city": "Columbus",
     "state": "OH",
     "score": 5.5,
     "why": [
      "same strategy: redevelop",
      "also in OH"
     ]
    },
    {
     "id": "m-df4cb8b48f",
     "name": "Beechmont Mall",
     "city": "Anderson Township",
     "state": "OH",
     "score": 5.5,
     "why": [
      "same strategy: redevelop",
      "also in OH"
     ]
    },
    {
     "id": "m-9d136a7521",
     "name": "City Centre Mart",
     "city": "Middletown",
     "state": "OH",
     "score": 5.5,
     "why": [
      "same strategy: redevelop",
      "also in OH"
     ]
    },
    {
     "id": "m-e2cae8fb7e",
     "name": "Cortana Mall",
     "city": "Baton Rouge",
     "state": "LA",
     "score": 5.5,
     "why": [
      "closed 2021",
      "same strategy: redevelop"
     ]
    },
    {
     "id": "m-d752c4a2d8",
     "name": "Eastland Mall",
     "city": "Columbus",
     "state": "OH",
     "score": 5.5,
     "why": [
      "closed 2022",
      "same strategy: redevelop",
      "also in OH"
     ]
    },
    {
     "id": "m-967ff89646",
     "name": "Findlay Village Mall",
     "city": "Findlay",
     "state": "OH",
     "score": 5.5,
     "why": [
      "closed 2025",
      "same strategy: redevelop",
      "also in OH"
     ]
    }
   ],
   "method": "size, era, strategy, status, type, state, distance"
  },
  "permits": {
   "county": "Stark County",
   "2024": {
    "units_1": 371,
    "units_2_4": 73,
    "units_5plus": 84,
    "value_total": 167792833
   },
   "2023": {
    "units_1": 361,
    "units_2_4": 71,
    "units_5plus": 77,
    "value_total": 157603619
   },
   "retrieved": "2026-10-18"
  },
  "qcew_retail": {
   "county": "39151",
   "year": 2025,
   "establishments": 1154,
   "employment": 18946,
   "avg_annual_pay": 35119,
   "lq_employment": 1.22,
   "employment_change_1y": -1.0,
   "source": "BLS QCEW 2025 annual, county, NAICS 44-45 retail trade, private",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "retail_trend": {
   "2012": {
    "estab": 1270,
    "emp": 20178
   },
   "2023": {
    "estab": 1179,
    "emp": 20169
   },
   "estab_change": -0.072,
   "emp_change": -0.0,
   "county_fips": "39151"
  },
  "schools": {
   "district": "Alliance City School District",
   "district_geoid": "3904349",
   "grades": "PK-12",
   "district_vintage": "SY2024-25",
   "public_schools_1mi": 3,
   "schools": [
    "Alliance High School",
    "Alliance Early Learning School",
    "Alliance Preschool"
   ],
   "schools_vintage": "SY2023-24",
   "source": "NCES EDGE",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "storms": {
   "county": "39151",
   "years": "2016-2025",
   "events": 131,
   "by_type": {
    "Thunderstorm Wind": 85,
    "Hail": 24,
    "Flood": 7,
    "Flash Flood": 7,
    "Tornado": 6,
    "Lightning": 1,
    "Funnel Cloud": 1
   },
   "property_damage_usd": 11739500,
   "deaths_direct": 1,
   "injuries_direct": 0,
   "note": "county-typed events only; events logged to forecast zones (CZ_TYPE Z: most winter, heat, flood and coastal events) are not counted",
   "source": "NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, details files",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  },
  "traffic": {
   "max_aadt": 10404,
   "trucks_aadt": 369,
   "road": "S UNION AVE",
   "class": "principal arterial",
   "lanes": 2,
   "segments_600m": 20,
   "year": "2024",
   "source": "FHWA HPMS",
   "retrieved": "2026-10-20"
  }
 },
 "parcels": [],
 "url": "https://retrofitatlas.org/malls/oh/alliance-carnation-city-mall/",
 "photo": null,
 "provenance": {
  "year_closed": "newtypes-extraction",
  "status": "newtypes-extraction",
  "after_notes": "newtypes-extraction",
  "year_retrofit": "newtypes-extraction"
 }
}