Retrofit Atlas

Malls · Ohio

Sandusky Mall

Imported, unreviewedRedevelopedReinhabitedUnder constructionSandusky, OH

Sandusky Mall is actively redeveloping into mixed-use (housing/retail/entertainment) under Cafaro Company, with construction ongoing since 2019 and housing permits issued in 2023–2024. Opportunity score is 0.0 due to active development. · summary, model-written

Ask who owns this Download dossier (PDF) · early access Download record (JSON) API Share LinkedIn Correct this record

Solid = from the authors' map · outlined = public source · dashed = model-written, not yet reviewed by a person. Tap any value's source label to see where it came from. documented = a quoted excerpt (click to read it) · reported = a source named, no excerpt yet · no source.

Map view. No verified photo yet. Send one.

Site profile12 elements · what this retrofit is built with · tap a chip for the evidence

Former anchors
JCPenneyThis site: JCPenney wikipedia · all sites with this
Montgomery WardThis site: Montgomery Ward wikipedia · all sites with this
Finance and pipeline
Retrofit in the pipelineThis site: …under construction newtypes-extraction · all sites with this
Place
30,000+ vehicles a day on an adjacent roadThis site: 34,332 on MILAN RD fhwa-hpms · all sites with this
Shrinking countyThis site: -0.3% census-acs · all sites with this
Strategy
RedevelopedThis site: …mixed-used property to feature retail, residential, entertainment, and office space record · all sites with this
ReinhabitedThis site: …mixed-used property to feature retail, residential, entertainment, and office space record · all sites with this
New use
Entertainment and sportsThis site: …mixed-used property to feature retail, residential, entertainment, and office space newtypes-extraction · all sites with this
HousingThis site: …mixed-used property to feature retail, residential, entertainment, and office space newtypes-extraction · all sites with this
Mixed useThis site: …new_use field newtypes-extraction · all sites with this
OfficeThis site: …property to feature retail, residential, entertainment, and office space newtypes-extraction · all sites with this
Retail (continued)This site: …mixed-used property to feature retail, residential, entertainment, and office space newtypes-extraction · all sites with this

All elements and lists · Trends

Now

StatusUnder constructionnewtypes-extraction reported
StrategyRedevelopment · Reinhabitation, under constructionWikipedia no source
New usesentertainment, housing, mixed, office, retailWikipedia no source
What is there nowmixed-used property to feature retail, residential, entertainment, and office spacenewtypes-extraction reported
Retrofit year2019newtypes-extraction reported
RedeveloperCafaro Companynewtypes-extraction reported

Site context

Housing permits, Erie County (OH), 20240 units in 5+ unit buildings, 6 in 2–4, 107 single-family; 2023: 17 in 5+Census BPS
Retail trade in the county, 2025 (BLS QCEW)5,194 jobs in 293 establishments; average annual pay $36,947; employment location quotient 1.44; employment +3.2% on the yearBLS QCEW 2025, NAICS 44-45, private
Jobs located in the tract, 20224,826 jobs; 1,510 in retail trade, 1,011 in accommodation and food (workplace blocks summed to tract 39043041900)Census LEHD LODES8 WAC 2022
Upward mobility (Opportunity Atlas, 2010 tract)children of low-income (25th percentile) families reached the 44th income percentile as adults; 1.8% incarcerated at the 2010 count (145 children in the sample); born 1978–83, measured 2014–15Opportunity Insights
Food access (USDA FARA 2019, 2010 tract)low-access at 1 mile, not low-income; 28% of residents more than 1 mile from a supermarket; poverty rate 4.5%; median family income $83,274; 38 SNAP householdsUSDA ERS
SchoolsPerkins Local School District (PK-12); 1 public school within 1 mile: Meadowlawn Elementary SchoolNCES EDGE
Elevation607 ft above sea level at the site pointUSGS 3DEP
Storm events in the county, 2016-202570 county-logged events: 51 thunderstorm wind, 10 hail, 5 flash flood, 2 tornado; $5,560,000 property damage reported; forecast-zone events (most flood, winter and heat) not countedNOAA Storm Events
Homes for sale in ZIP 44870, 2026-09median list price $229,450 (-7.5% on the year); 134 active listings; median 52 days on market; 15% with a price cutRealtor.com Research
Retail trade in the county, 2012 to 2023301 establishments (-3%); 5,655 jobs (+22%)Census CBP
Housing market in the countytypical home value $240,422 (+3% 1 yr, +33% 5 yr); typical rent $1,812/mo (+11% 1 yr), 2026-09Zillow Research
Traffic on the busiest road within 600 m (2024)34,332 vehicles a day on MILAN RD (principal arterial, 4 lanes); 11 counted segmentsFHWA HPMS

Summary, model-written

Sandusky Mall (opened 1977) is under construction for redevelopment since 2019, led by Cafaro Company. The project aims to convert the site into mixed-use space with housing, retail, entertainment, and office components. Key developments include Hobby Lobby (2020), TJ Maxx (2021), Five Below (2021), and Tilt Studio (2024) opening in former anchor spaces. Traffic data shows high volume (34,332 ADT) on a principal arterial road. Housing market data indicates rising ZHVI ($240k, +3.4% YoY) in Erie County. The opportunity is marked as 'already in play' due to active construction and housing-focused plans. No current vacancy data or completion timeline is provided in the record.

Why. The assessment uses only the provided record: status, developer, timeline, new uses, traffic, housing market, and 'opp_reasons' explicitly state the site is under active development with housing plans.

Where it stands. Status: under construction (2019–present). New uses confirmed: retail (TJ Maxx, Five Below), entertainment (Tilt Studio), housing (permits show 2023–2024 residential units), office. No data on current occupancy or final completion date.

For a planner

  • High traffic volume supports retail/entertainment viability.
  • Housing permits indicate residential component is underway.
  • No data on community impact or displacement.

For a developer

  • Active construction and housing focus align with current strategy.
  • No new opportunity identified (record states 'already in play').
  • Anchor tenant transitions (e.g., Elder Beerman to Tilt Studio) show adaptive reuse.

What we do not know yet

  • No data on project cost, timeline, or final unit count.
  • No current vacancy rates or tenant mix details beyond listed openings.
  • Housing market growth rate (3.4% YoY) is noted but not contextualized.

Generated by qwen3-30b-a3b-64k:latest on Dell 5820 RTX 3090 (Ollama, qwen3-30b-a3b) from the fields, parcels, deals and context layers on this page, with no outside knowledge. It is regenerated when the record changes and has not been checked by a person. How it is made.

Similar sites

Elsewhere on the web

Search images: Google · Bing · Commons · references: ULI case studies · Google Scholar

Multifamily screen

  • already in play: under construction, approved, or sold to a developer with housing plans
  • housing in the record

Inputs: record fields (size, status) and county Census ACS 2018–2023 figures (growth, rent). How the points work. Not a recommendation.

History and original facts

Opened1977newtypes-extraction
AnchorsJCPenney, Montgomery Ward, May Co., Cohn Co.
CountyErie County
Census division3 · East North Central
NotesDraft from Wikipedia, model-extracted, unreviewed: Sandusky Mall is being transformed into a mixed-use property featuring retail, residential, entertainment, and office space, with new tenants occupying former anchor stores.

Not yet recorded: acres, GLA, original developer. Know it? Tell us.

Background

Sandusky Mall is an indoor shopping center located in Perkins Township, south of Sandusky, Ohio. It is located on the east side of US Route 250, north of I-80/I-90 (Ohio Turnpike) and Ohio State Route 2. It is the only major shopping center within 45 miles (72 km). It comprises more than 70 stores; the anchor stores are TJ Maxx, JCPenney, Books-A-Million, Dewey Furniture, Five Below, Tilt Studio, and Ross. JCPenney had previously operated a store in downtown Sandusky. It is managed by Cafaro Company of Niles, Ohio. == History == Mall construction began in 1976 and Sandusky Mall opened on March 16, 1977.

Excerpt from Wikipedia (authors and history), CC BY-SA 4.0. May be older than the record above.

Timeline

  1. 1977 Opened
  2. 2018 Cafaro Company announced a redevelopment plan for the mall.
  3. 2019 Hobby Lobby announced to replace half of the former Sears store.
  4. 2019 Retrofit: redevelop, reinhabit
  5. 2020 Hobby Lobby opened.
  6. 2020 TJ Maxx announced to open in new location inside the mall in 2021.
  7. 2020 Five Below announced to open near Hobby Lobby in 2021.
  8. 2020 Another Broken Egg Cafe announced to open in 2021.
  9. 2021 Five Below opened.
  10. 2021 TJ Maxx opened its new store.
  11. 2022 Ross Dress for Less opened a new store.
  12. 2024 Tilt Studio opened in the former Elder Beerman anchor store.

Sources

  • Sandusky Mall · CC BY-SA 4.0
    11 quoted sentences
    Sandusky Mall
    In December 2018, Cafaro Company announced that they had a redevelopment plan set in place for the mall with changes on the horizon coming within the next year.
    On June 30, 2019, it was announced that Hobby Lobby, a crafts and home decor store, would be coming to the Sandusky Mall. It replaced roughly half of the former Sears store.
    It opened March 23, 2020.

More in Ohio

Anderson MallCincinnati, OH · 2003Partial Regreened · Partial regreening, parkBeechmont MallAnderson Township, OH · 2003Redeveloped · Regreened · Redevelopment: retail, office, civic, street grid Partial…City CenterColumbus, OH · 2011Redeveloped · Regreened · Regreening: park Partial redevelopment: mixed-use residentialCity Centre MartMiddletown, OH · 2001Redeveloped · Redevelopment: restored street gridPortside Festival MarketplaceToledo, OH · 1997Reinhabited · Reinhabitation: science museumRichland MallRichland MallOntario, OH · 2015Partial Reinhabited · Partial reinhabitation: healthcare